Paint vs. Solid Stain for Exterior Home Siding

Paint vs. Stain for Exterior Home Siding

While paint and solid stain might look similar at first glance, there are important differences between the two. The biggest one is that paint sticks to the surface, while stain absorbs into the wood.

Stain has some obvious advantages; especially its ability to handle changing weather. It expands and contracts with the wood and allows it to breathe. On the other hand, paint forms a thick layer that dries faster and typically requires fewer coats because it’s thicker. However, if the wood is very absorbent, you may need more stain to achieve adequate coverage.

Deciding Which To Use

Stain

When choosing between stain or paint for exterior wood, it’s important to consider the condition of the wood. Solid stain works well on fresh, untreated wood because it soaks in better than paint and often doesn’t need a primer. But it’s not a good choice for surfaces that have already been painted.

Solid stain is a great option for new wood siding such as cedar shingles, or lapped siding, as it seals the wood and saves time and money by not requiring a primer. While it’s not ideal to apply stain over paint, you can easily paint over a solid stain later. For new homes, solid stain can be a smart option during the first few years.

Paint

Despite the benefits of stain, paint usually offers more protection, lasts longer, and comes in a wider variety of colors. When used on a previously painted or sealed surface, solid stain can look similar to paint but doesn’t provide the same level of protection or longevity.

Solid stains tend to fade faster than paint, which means they need to be reapplied more often. Because of this, paint is generally the better choice. However, if you’re working with bare wood and want to preserve its texture, solid stain can still be a good option.

Ultimately, the decision between paint and stain comes down to personal preference, location, climate, and the condition of the surface you’re working with. 

Bullet Points

Stain:

• Stain is usually cheaper than paint.

• It’s easier to apply and touch up when needed.

• Since stain often doesn’t require primer, the process is faster and usually only needs one coat.

• It enhances the natural look of wood, giving it a rugged, natural appearance.

• Stain is less likely to chip, while paint tends to peel, crack, or flake over time.

Paint:

• Paint comes in a wider variety of colors.

• It gives a smoother and more consistent finish.

• There are more options in terms of sheens and finishes.

• Paint can be applied over previous paint jobs (after prepping), while stain can’t.